Week 46: #52 Ancestors – Random Fact
By Eilene Lyon
“Benjamin Hull Jones, a native of Ohio, became dissipated, and by accident shot away a large portion of his face.”
I found that statement more random and shocking than anything I’ve come across in my decades of research. When I began examining the life of Dr. Benjamin H. Jones, I wasn’t aware of our family connection. He and his brother, Samuel Jones, are key figures in my gold rush story. Later, I discovered that they are my first cousins, four times removed.
From a Jones family member, who has a Bible transcript belonging to Benjamin and Samuel’s younger brother, William, I learned that Benjamin died in March 1864. Because he was a doctor, I began searching for personal information about him in county history books. They invariably profile doctors, lawyers, politicians, and prominent businessmen.
What I found was that single sentence at the top of this article. Nothing more. It led me to assume two things: He died from the gunshot and it was probably a suicide. Both assumptions proved to be incorrect.
I won’t give you Benjamin’s full story here – he is a central figure in my book – but I will tell you that his sad situation has seared my soul. As Walt Whitman put it, I wish to “discorrupt” him and rebuild his tragically exploded life. But we don’t get to resurrect the dead and fix their problems, anymore than we can change our own past.
Because of his role in procuring the funds, Benjamin H. Jones was the principal witness in a lawsuit against his brother, Samuel, and 15 other men. The suit arose from the debt they incurred to finance the trip to California.
On December 30, 1853, Benjamin gave a deposition in the case, because the parties in the suit thought he would die from his injuries. That is how I discovered when, where, and how the accidental gunshot occurred. When he surprisingly testified in court the following March, he detailed the damage to his face that he lived with for the 10 remaining years of his life.
After the Civil War, and later, after World War I, such facial deformities would become a regular sight, but it was probably uncommon in the 1850s. I randomly came across an essay that shed some light on what it must have been like for Benjamin and someone encountering him.
“In my neighborhood there walks a man who…has had the left side of his face blown away. Where features once were, a drape of flesh has been drawn. He is small, tidy, wears a cap, and through his walk and general demeanor gives an impression of thoughtfulness. The effect upon first seeing him is jolting. Life must be hard for him, and one wonders if he has ever grown inured to watching strangers recoil upon initial sight of him. But why is one jolted, why does one recoil? As much as from anything, I think it has to do with one’s inability to read his face. One cannot sense his mood or know what he is (even roughly) thinking – and the result is disconcerting in the extreme.”
I have never found any photos of Benjamin Jones. However, I do have photos of his sister, Rebecca, brother, William, and daughter, Lucetta:
Feature image: Home of Dr. Emma B. Lewis in Camden (now Pennville), Indiana, about 1880. Dr. Benjamin Jones lived in Camden, but never owned property there. He was a poor physician living in humble circumstances, probably something more like the modest building to the left of Dr. Lewis’s fine home. (H. H. Hardesty & Co. 1881)
Sources:
Biographical and Historical Record of Jay and Blackford Counties, Indiana. 1887. The Lewis Publishing Co., Chicago. p. 210.
Epstein, Joseph. “About Face.” 1991. Published in The Oxford Book of Essays. Oxford University Press. p. 671.
Historical Hand-Atlas Illustrated, Containing…Twelve Farm Maps and History of Jay County, Indiana 1881. H. H. Hardesty & Co., Chicago and Toledo.
Makepeace v. Samuel Jones et al. 1851. Delaware County Circuit Court. Available online at Delaware County Record Image Search: http://digitalresource.munpl.org/default.asp?PageIndex=800
You have such an intriguing family history! I now want to know Dr. Jones story! Good way to keep us anticipating your book!
LikeLiked by 2 people
I wish it would write itself so I could get it published! 😁
LikeLiked by 1 person
Very intriguing – I want to hear the whole story now. 😃
LikeLiked by 2 people
The gold rush had negative impacts on so many lives. It was almost like a war in that way.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I can imagine. All the competing for claims, it must have pitted so many men against each other. Desperate times!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I was introduced to several “nightwalkders” on one of my first ride-alongs with the police. There are people everywhere who prefer to get their exercise and fresh air in the privacy of the night because of their disfigurements.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Understandable. I know that in the historic past, many wore masks, but that fell out of favor (I would think they’d be uncomfortable).
LikeLike
People deal with their troubles in different ways. I feel sorry for the doctor, and wonder if he thought he was doing the world a favor by not being in it anymore? Who knows, eh?
LikeLiked by 2 people
I don’t think he ever attempted suicide. But I suspect his life was filled with sorrow.
LikeLiked by 1 person
What a sad story, Eilene! Thank you for sharing. That newspaper headline about Benjamin Hull Jones… that certainly got readers’ attention!
I too have several gold rushers in my family. For two of them, their stories did not end well: https://kindredconnection.wordpress.com/2011/03/13/four_francis_ancestors/
LikeLiked by 2 people
So many people died like that. I really was a terrible ordeal for many.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Oh how sad… the things you find! That essay really brings it to life even more too. I bet your book is fantastic!
LikeLiked by 2 people
Thanks, M.B.!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Oh dear, poor Benjamin! Full face transplants are being covered in the media recently, such sad stories; I cannot imagine how hard it must have been back then, surviving the accident without much treatment.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I think he had a really strong will to live. Maybe living in a small community was helpful. People tended to take accidents in stride – a fact of life.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I have found from experience stories such as these are a reward for pursuing genealogy.
LikeLiked by 1 person
They do help us think of them as more than just names and dates and make us ponder what their lives were really like, I agree. Thanks for reading!
LikeLike