Paintersville, Ohio

Week 25: #52 Ancestors – Unexpected

By Eilene Lyon

I’ve long known that there are pioneers of many stripes in my family background. But I didn’t expect one of them to have been the first settler in Cæsers Creek Township, Greene County, Ohio – a location that is less than 20 miles from where I finished high school in the same county. I did not discover this until long after I permanently left Ohio, of course.

Greene County 1855
Map of Caesars Creek Township, Greene County, Ohio, from an 1855 map. Click to see larger version.

David Painter, born in Winchester, Virginia, in 1761, was part of a group of Quakers who chose to move to the Northwest Territory around 1800, because it would remain free of the institution of slavery, an affront to their religious beliefs.

Arriving first in Waynesville, now in Warren County, the Painter family followed an Indian trail to stake a claim near the creek that bears their name. This trek took place in the spring of 1802. They built a cabin and planted their first crops: potatoes and corn.

David Painter and his wife, Martha “Patsy” Faulkner, were the grandparents of my ancestor, William Walter Painter. William Painter was the second settler in Winneshiek County, Iowa, so he had a role model for his wandering ways.

Martha and David had four children. Hannah was the eldest. Next was Jesse. Then came Jacob. The youngest, Thomas J. Painter, was my 4th great-grandfather. Hannah, then age 16, and Jesse remained in the family cabin during the winter of 1802-3 to protect the family claim, while the rest of the family returned to Waynesville for a time.

Paintersville GE
Current Google Earth satellite image of the area settled by the Painter family in 1802.

One history of Greene County waxed eloquent about the character of David Painter and family:

“At the time of the Painter family’s settlement here, there were only three cabins between Painter’s cabin home and Waynesville, but soon afterward other settlers of the same creed of this sturdy Quaker flocked into the township, and a Friends society was organized. Painter himself was instrumental in the organization of this society. The death of this old settler occurred about 1840 and since that year all of his children have followed him to the grave.

“The Painters were ideal settlers, for they were a thrifty, steady and yet enterprising family. Moreover, their adherence to the creed of the Friends was instrumental in their becoming valuable and moral citizens of the new county and neighborhood. Even though the teaching of the Friends is against war, this first settler of the township waxed warlike when it seemed that a wholesale butchery of whites impended after Hull’s surrender at Detroit.

“On that Sabbath morning when the news of the disaster arrived in the settlement, David Painter, under the exigency of the moment, shouldered his rifle and march[ed] off to join the volunteers who were hastening to Urbana to protect the Ohio settlements from the Indians who were reported to be coming southward.”

Plat of Paintersville 1896 LOC
Plat of Paintersville from Riddell’s Greene County atlas, 1896. (Library of Congress) Click to view larger.

Jesse Painter had a farm near his parents and in 1837 he decided to formally plat a village around his business establishment:

“Before the village was laid out, the site was a part of the farm of one hundred and fifty acres which belonged to Jesse Painter, a son of David Painter, the first settler of Caesarscreek township. Before the town was laid out Jesse Painter and Jonathan Oglesbee owned country stores on its site, where the residents of the surrounding country came to purchase their supplies.

“A short time before 1840 Painter decided that the modest trading point could take upon itself the dignity of a village of considerable importance and since he was the owner of the surrounding land he secured the services of Moses Collier, the county surveyor, who platted the village in the latter part of the summer of 1837. The work was finished on September 7,1837, and on the 16th of the same month the plat was received for record and recorded by J. H. McPherson, the county recorder…”

StitchPainter 1-Painter 2
Three scenes from Paintersville (top, lower middle, bottom) from about 1908. (Public domain). Click to view larger.

Jesse sold his 55 lots for 20 or 25 dollars each, depending on location. Paintersville was the only village in the township, but today, though it is still on the map, it is just a residential community. The post office closed in 1910.

Also unexpected is that these ancestors on my paternal side were contemporaneously living not far from some of my ancestors on my maternal side. I haven’t found any crossovers in their family trees, but who knows? It could happen someday.

Feature image: Home of Jesse and Elizabeth (Smith) Painter in Paintersville in mid-1800s. (Courtesy of BrickyardBum on


Broadstone, M.A. ed. 1918. History of Greene County, Ohio: Its People, Industries and Institutions, Vol. 1. B.F. Bowen & Company, Inc., Indianapolis, pp. 227-234.

Robinson, George F. 1902. History of Greene County, Ohio. The S.J. Clarke Publishing Company, Chicago, pp. 562-4.

30 thoughts on “Paintersville, Ohio

Add yours

    1. That is quite a broad topic, for sure. I think there’s going to be a bit of backlash against the impermanence of our current communications style. If not, then it will be interesting to see what media takes charge of the perception of this present time in the future.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. I agree! There are several local histories of Candia, New Hampshire that have provided invaluable information about my Brown ancestors, some of it incorrect, but still valuable as the perception of that time and place.

        Liked by 1 person

      2. True. My mother was quite disgusted with the effusive praise of her great-great grandfather Benjamin Franklin Brown. She was not a fan of purple prose of any sort. Me, I find 19th-century purple prose amusing.

        Liked by 1 person

  1. I’ve always found the Quakers interesting. On the one hand they come across very dogmatic and unyielding, and then out of the blue they do something surprising. I wonder how he rationalized it? Or how he was treated by the Friends when he returned?

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Since he was apparently a leader of that group, I doubt he was seriously chastised. Plus, self-defense has to count for something. I don’t really know the particulars of their anti-war credo.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. They’re pacifists, though there are always a few who’ll break ranks to join a cause and risk losing their good standing with the Friends. Their general philosophy is that violence causes more problems than it solves.

        Liked by 1 person

  2. Waynesville and Caeser’s Creek I’m aware of, but I’ve never heard of Paintersville OH. It must have been significant enough to warrant being surveyed. I wonder if Moses Collier is an ancestor of the family in Springfield OH who published Collier Encyclopedias? A rhetorical question.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. I always thought I knew Ohio pretty well, but you keep mentioning these places I’ve never heard of (I think I know NE Ohio well, but the rest of it…not so much!). Nice to hear of some anti-slavery Ohioans for once – I know Ohio was home to lots of abolitionists in the 19th century, but it seems like I just keep encountering racist Ohioans these days!

    Liked by 1 person

Please share your thoughts...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Create a website or blog at

Up ↑

Moore Genealogy

Fun With Genealogy

My Slice of Mexico

Discover and re-discover Mexico’s cuisine, culture and history through the recipes, backyard stories and other interesting findings of an expatriate in Canada

Waking up on the Wrong Side of 50

Navigating the second half of my life

The Willamette Valley's Heritage through its Barns and Structures

A history of the people of the Willamette Valley as revealed through their structures.

A Dalectable Life

Doing the best I can to keep it on the bright side


You might think you understand what I said, but what you heard is not always what I meant.

Tumblereads: A New Twist on the Old West

A New Twist on the Old West

Eilene Lyon

Author, Speaker, Family Historian


thoughts about life from below the surface

Northwest Journals

tiny histories

Ancestral Writing in Progress

... stories of significant others in the Allery, Cutting, McCulloch and Robertson tribes ...

Coach Carole Ramblings

Celtic, Mythical and More ...

Shedding Light on the Family Tree

Illuminating the Ancestral Journey

Forgotten Ancestors

Tracing The Faces

The Patchwork Genealogist

Uncovering Family Legacies One Stitch at a Time

Family Finds

Adventures in Genealogy

What's Going On @ ACGSI

Allen County Genealogical Society of Indiana Blog

sue clancy

visual stories: fine art, artist books, illustrated gifts

Ask the Agent

Night Thoughts of a Literary Agent

%d bloggers like this: